UFOP: EU oilseed producers lose in Argentina imports settlement

February 4, 2019

BY UFOP

According to Germany’s Union for the Promotion of Oil and Protein Plants (UFOP), European oilseed producers are the losers in the Jan. 30 decision of the representatives of the EU member states in the Trade Defense Instruments Committee (TDI). The association criticizes the committee’s approval of the Argentine government’s proposal for a so-called “price undertaking” agreement, which will allow Argentina’s biodiesel producers to export around 1.2 million metric tons (approximately 360 million gallons) of biodiesel duty-free to the EU every year.

This amount of biodiesel accounts for 10 percent of total biodiesel consumption in the European Union. This market access is coupled with compliance with a minimum import price, which is to be calculated on the basis of monthly average soybean oil prices. The concrete and legally binding calculation procedure will be announced in the EU Official Journal. UFOP fears that as a result of the procedure for setting the minimum import price, which is not yet known in detail, market access will be ensured through a price level that will have an overall negative effect on the EU biodiesel price and consequently on oilseed producer prices. Biodiesel quantities that exceed this import quota are subject to company-specific countervailing duties between 25 and 33.4 percent.

In this context, UFOP refers to the pending case against Indonesia. Perhaps the agreement concluded with Argentina is a blueprint for an analogous agreement with the Indonesian government. This would undermine the political decision of the European Parliament, which had argued in favor of a palm oil ban, and thus the issue of regulating indirect land-use change.

Another reason for UFOP’s critical assessment is the fact that the recast Renewable Energy Directive (2018/1999/EC) re-authorizes member states to lower the capping limit of 7 percent set by EU law below the national capping limit for biofuels from cultivated biomass in the upcoming national implementation. What the respective national implementation will look like is not yet known. It is clear, however, that in the worst case, the import base of 1.2 million tons of biodiesel from Argentina will remain in a shrinking market for this commodity.

Advertisement

From UFOP’s point of view, it is incomprehensible that the definition of this import volume did not take into account the disappearance of the U.K.’s consumption share due to Brexit, along with the share of biodiesel from waste oils and fats. In 2017, the consumption of biodiesel from these waste materials in Germany alone amounted to about 0.84 million tons or 38 percent of the total consumption of 2.21 million tons of biodiesel.

UFOP notes that politics is currently unable to answer the question of which measures can be used to secure oilseed production in the European Union as the most important source of genetically modified-free protein feed for the future. In this sense, Argentina is a double winner because the possibly reduced cultivation of rapeseed in the European Union means that more soybean meal needs to be imported. An environmental policy strategy cannot be identified in this agreement.

Advertisement

Related Stories

Calumet on Jan. 28 announced disbursement of the first tranche of its $1.44 billion U.S. DOEloan guarantee to support the expansion of SAF production at its Montana Renewables facility will be delayed to allow review by the Trump administration.

Read More

The Trump administration has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to pause the small refinery exemption (SRE) lawsuit currently pending before the court while the agency “reassesses the basis for and the soundness of the denial actions.”

Read More

The U.S. Senate on Jan. 29 voted 56 to 42 to confirm Lee Zeldin to serve as administrator of the U.S. EPA. Representatives of the biofuels industry are congratulating Zeldin and expressing confidence he will keep the RFS on track.

Read More

Rep. Beth Van Duyne, R-Texas, on Jan. 16 introduced a bill that aims to repeal the Section 45Z clean fuel production credit. The tax credit, established by the IRA, supports the production of various low-carbon transportation fuels.

Read More

SAF Magazine, in collaboration with the CAAFI, has announced the 2025 North American SAF Conference & Expo will be held Sept. 22-24 in Minneapolis, Minnesota, at the Minneapolis Convention Center. Speaker abstracts can be submitted through May 9.

Read More

Upcoming Events

Sign up for our e-newsletter!

Advertisement

Advertisement