Authentication, not validation

New program unveiled to authenticate biodiesel feedstock as "renewable biomass" could help put final piece of puzzle in place for RIN assurance
By Ron Kotrba | December 19, 2012

I had an in-depth conversation recently, as well as various correspondences over the past few months, with Ramon Benavides—who many of you may know or at least his name rings a bell for you, as he is fairly well-known in biodiesel circles—on the topic of a new feedstock authentication program his company, Global Renewable Energy Strategies and Consulting, developed in partnership with Gorge Analytical. The result of those conversations was a story I published yesterday on titled “Program launched to authenticate feedstock as ‘renewable biomass.’”

As I write in the article, it may seem common sense that fuels qualified under the renewable fuel standard must be made from renewable biomass, but Ray says proving this is not an easy task for producers. In fact, he estimates that if biodiesel producers had to prove their feedstock meets the totality of the definitions of “renewable biomass,” 90 percent of them couldn’t do it. I say totality of definitions because, as Ray reminds me, there are several statutes, codes, sections, subsections and parts to various laws of multiple government agencies—the EPA’s RFS and the Clean Air Act, the IRS and the USDA—that cross-reference and create a complex web of compliance obligations that could make anyone’s head spin. Anyone except Ray’s that is.

The program, called the Feedstock Conformance Protocol, is designed to authenticate RINs on the frontend through a rigorous feedstock testing program, using the expertise of Jeff and Michelle Fetkenhour (Gorge Analytical), rather than validating RINs on the backend.

Ray says feedstock contaminants he has seen include PCBs, ethylene glycol, sulfur, heavy metals like chromium and even motor oils. Just before publication of the article, Ray told me his program caught concentrations of contamination in feedstock that saved the purchaser about $2 million.

The program provides a feedstock profile to the producer before it arrives at the plant. Ray also says he is working with EPA, biodiesel producers, and QAP and feedstock providers, and notes that none of the QAPs on the market have this central component in their program. He also points out that the FCP is complementary to all existing QAPs, and he says it was specifically designed to not cost small producers “an arm and a leg.”

Check out the link to the story above, and let me know your thoughts on the program, and its role in authenticating biodiesel RINs via feedstock testing.

1 Responses

  1. Alexandre



    Review by David Stebbins for Rating: Despite Federal tax credits (up to 30% of the total cost, inucidlng installation) for solar water heating there's a lack of information on the subject. For a handyman with good plumbing skills, or a homeowner wanting to learn about solar water heating, this is the best book available. After a history of solar water heating in the US, the book describes various systems that use the sun to heat and store water. Climate, freeze conditions, water quality and amount of sunlight available are some of the factors considered in choosing a system, and the book describes them all. Individual components are detailed in a logical, straightforward way. It's obvious the authors have extensive practical knowledge. The writing style is informal and easy to read. Besides all the solar water heating information, this book also has a good section on radiant floor heating, detailing the use of PEX tubing to heat a concrete slab. The book uses a lot of drawings to demonstrate how things work. More actual photographs of systems and components would have been helpful. I also wish the authors would have included brand names and sources for equipment. The industry still suffers from the stigma of poorly designed systems of the 1970 s and 80 s. Some reassurances from the authors regarding which component manufacturers are good would have been nice. For the past five years, I've lived with a solar water heating system I bought as a package and installed myself. I've been happy with all the free hot water it's provided. If this book had been available when planning my system I would have had a much better idea of what I was doing. Having all the components matched and sized with specific instructions gave me a lot of confidence during installation. In my opinion, for the neophyte, a component package is a good way to go. For anyone planning a residential sized solar water heating system, this is the best book available. It's an excellent guide, whether you decide to choose the individual components yourself, buy a package, or hire a contractor to install a turnkey system. If you're a contractor or someone wanting to get into the solar water heating business, Solar Hot Water Systems Lessons Learned 1977 to Today (Tom Lane) is very good, but the amount of technical detail implies you already have a good working knowledge of plumbing and roofing. [...] Good luck getting into hot water!

  2. Leave a Reply

    Biodiesel Magazine encourages civil conversation and debate. However, we reserve the right to delete comments for reasons including but not limited to: any type of attack, injurious statements, profanity, business solicitations or other advertising.

    Comments are closed